Senior Market News & Updates | New Horizons Insurance Marketing Inc.

2026 Q1 Annuity Market Update: Why Stability and Support Matter More Than Ever

Written by New Horizons Staff | Mar 30, 2026 8:43:38 PM

As we move out of the first quarter of 2026, one thing has become undeniably clear: clients are seeking financial stability in a time of uncertainty. With global tensions disrupting markets and the Dow recently hitting its lowest point of the year, many consumers—especially retirees—are no longer interested in taking risks with their hard‑earned savings. This current climate has created a meaningful opportunity for agents: the chance to offer reliable protection through annuities.

But while products and rates matter, our biggest focus this quarter is something even more foundational: the Annuity Mentorship Program.

New Horizons Annuity Mentorship Program

The message driving the program is simple but powerful: “We will meet you where you are.” Whether agents want guidance through a single case or support across a full portfolio, the mentorship team is prepared to walk step by step through product selection, case design, and client conversations.

This is especially valuable for Medicare agents who already share strong, trusting relationships with their clients but may not feel fully confident discussing financial products. The mentorship program closes that gap by offering:

  • Case‑by‑case guidance and strategy
  • Support choosing the right product for each client scenario
  • Coaching to build confidence in financial discussions

Many agents underestimate how ready their Medicare clients are to have these conversations. Clients already trust their agents to help them navigate complicated choices. The mentorship program helps agents build on that trust and open the door to new, income‑expanding opportunities, using a tool you’ve heard us mention before, the Client Needs Assessment.

Carrier Highlights: What’s Driving Interest This Quarter

Product performance continues to strengthen the value proposition for annuities this quarter, and a few carriers stand out in particular.

CL Life

While overall activity has been a bit slower, CL Life’s Tarrant Trail product remains a strong option—especially for clients concerned about unpredictable markets. What draws attention first is its competitive rate structure:

But what agents find even more compelling is its bailout feature. If the renewal rate ever drops below 5% during years two through six, the client can walk away with no penalties. This level of flexibility gives clients both security and peace of mind. Once agents understand how the bailout works, it becomes one of the easiest products to recommend. Strong commissions only reinforce its appeal.

  • 7% fixed rate in the first year
  • 5% annually from years two through six

Note: Rates mentioned are subject to change. Accurate as of March 19, 2026.

Heartland National Life

Heartland continues to dominate the MYGA market with excellent rates and a reputation for stability. Their lineup remains one of the most competitive available:

The 10‑year product, in particular, has become an appealing solution for clients who want predictable income. Because interest withdrawals can begin after 30 days, it offers both steady growth and immediate liquidity. For example, a client depositing $250,000 could generate $15,000 per year—about $1,000 a month—while keeping their entire principal intact. In a market where losses feel all too common, this type of predictability resonates deeply with retirees.

  • 3‑year MYGA at 5.5%
  • 5‑year MYGA at 5.9%
  • 10‑year MYGA at 6%

 Note: Rates mentioned are subject to change. Accurate as of March 19, 2026.

Market Conditions: Why Annuities Are in High Demand

The start of 2026 has proven challenging for traditional investments. With the Dow slipping to its lowest level of the year and volatility driven by global instability, clients are naturally gravitating toward safe, interest‑bearing products. Annuities, particularly MYGAs and Fixed Indexed Annuities (FIAs), offer the reassurance clients want right now.

MYGAs have become especially attractive because rates in the 5–6% range are a dramatic improvement over the 3% average seen just a few years ago. Clients who were once skeptical of fixed products are now reconsidering them, especially when compared to inconsistent market performance.

FIAs add another layer of appeal for clients rolling over 401(k)s or preparing for retirement. They offer market‑linked growth without market risk. Even if the index performs poorly, the client can never lose principal—and the annual reset feature means gains captured in one year become the new protected baseline.

A simple example explains the value clearly:

A client invests $25,000 and gains $10,000 in the first year, bringing their total to $35,000. If the market drops the following year, they stay at $35,000. For clients in their 60s and 70s, avoiding losses is often more important than maximizing gains, making FIAs a natural fit.

The Strength of Our Partnership with Brokers International

Beyond product access and market conditions, our long‑standing relationship with Brokers International continues to be one of our strongest resources. As an Integrity partner, their team provides support on complex case design, advanced technology tools, and expanded carrier access. More importantly, they share our commitment to prioritizing the client’s best interest. This partnership predates our involvement with Integrity and remains a cornerstone of our annuity strategy.

Guidance for Newer Agents: Start Simple and Build Confidence

For agents who feel unsure about entering the annuity space, the best place to begin is with MYGAs. Their simplicity— “a set rate for a set period” —makes them easy to explain to clients and easier to understand from a sales perspective.

Agents should also take advantage of the educational resources available, including videos, blogs, and recorded webinars featuring real agent experiences.

But above all, the strongest recommendation remains the Annuity Mentorship ProgramIt takes the confusion out, builds your confidence, and helps you start simple conversations with clients you already serve.

Conclusion

Instead of leading with product updates or rate sheets, we are leading with mentorship. This shift encourages agents to reach out earlier, engage more fully, and start conversations with clients long before choosing a product. From there, product updates, rate highlights, and market commentary support the bigger goal: helping you gain the confidence you need to write more annuity business.