Top 7 Medicare Supplement Carriers for the 2021/2022 AEP

Top 7 Medicare Supplement Carriers for the 2021/2022 AEP
September 20, 2021

AEP is right around the corner – here are the top 7 Medicare Supplements carriers we’re watching to make a big impact this selling season.

These carriers are listed in no particular order.

7. Elips / Lumico Medigap Solutions


Elips is really gaining traction in our sales force. We're seeing their numbers grow every single week, and we look for the fourth quarter to be no exception.

With the underwriting and the business that's flowing out of the great state of Indiana, it seems like Elips has a lot of momentum. We look forward to seeing what the numbers are as we close out 2021.

As a reminder, here are a few highlights:

  • Some of the lowest rates in the market
  • 12% household discount
  • Strong, fast start incentives
  • An easy, streamlined app process
  • Enhanced application, which will increase the auto-approval rate by 2-3%

Get contracted with Lumico Medigap Solutions (Elips)

6. American Benefit Life (ABL)


American Benefit Life, or ABL, is a sister company to Capitol Life. We've had a great run with Capitol Life.

We've been working on ABL with Marty Martin, the President, and the owner, Brad Phillips, for over a year.

ABL has the red, green, and yellow underwriting that those who wrote Capitol Life love. We feel like ABL is going to be one of our home runs. We're excited and anxious to see how you see that company in your portfolio.

Don't forget all of the incredible highlights of ABL:

  • Highly competitive rates make ABL's plans attractive to your clients
  • On-the-spot underwriting — most agents receive an underwriting decision in minutes rather than days or even weeks
  • Powerful mobile app that gives you access to our on-the-Spot tools in one place, making the entire process as streamlined as possible
  • Effortless medication lookup tool is just one tool in the app and lets you search medications by name and automatically indicates any impacts on our plans
  • Administered by Aetna
  • $500 fast start bonus through September 30, 2021
  • Incredible incentive trip to Portugal
  • Fantastic, enhanced 10% Household Discount with a broad definition
  • E-app only – no paper apps with this product

Get contracted with American Benefit Life (ABL)

5. ManhattanLife (MAC)


MAC is absolutely doing a great job for us. They are killing it across the nation. We all know that we've had a rich background with ManhattanLife, going back to American Family Life. The underwriting, the service – it's all second to none.

In your state, you might find MAC or ManhattanLife to be a great player for you.

A few highlights:

  • Same underwriting and e-App as ManhattanLife
  • Better commissions and new, competitive rates that will make it more profitable for you and more attractive to your clients
  • One of the best e-Apps in the market, featuring an ultra-simple signature process that makes selling over the phone effortless
  • 7% Household Discount, one policy to qualify
  • Admin in Houston is some of the best

Get contracted with MAC

4. Aetna/Accendo/CVS Health

accendo logo

Aetna and Accendo continue to throw numbers into the industry of sales records and this is not slowing down! We are still getting a large number of agents coming on with Accendo and Aetna.

They continue to lead the industry in sales, and we have no problems with the folks out of Tennessee just doing a great job of taking care of the customers.

They also have great rewards as you go forward, and we're so happy and thankful that we have a great relationship with Accendo.

Product highlights:

  • Brand recognition – Accendo is part of the CVS Health® family of companies and an Aetna affiliate
  • 14% HHD – one of the highest discounts from any carrier today
  • Competitive rates – great rates everywhere, particularly on F and G
  • Great about instant decisions
  • Super user-friendly e-App – same platform as Aetna and Capitol Life
  • Med Supp Bonus Program – You can combine your Aetna and Accendo production for the bonus program

Get contracted with Accendo/CVS Health

3. Medico


Another new player with a familiar face to us is Medico. Medico has come back into the Medicare Supplement market, and they're doing something a little different than the average player out there.

They're really going after the metropolitan areas – areas that you'd normally consider to be a strong Medicare Advantage area. Most of our other carriers have no interest in the metro areas, and Medico has carved out a niche there. If you live in these areas or have business in a metropolitan area, Medico is a great player for you.

They've only been out a short while, but my goodness are they hitting some big numbers. It's one of the biggest launches of the year.

Here are some highlights of the new face of Medico:

  • Competitive rates and generous commissions
  • Fast start incentive program through December 31, 2021 – earn up to $450!
  • A bundle-and-save discount on a Dental policy
  • Easy-to-use MyEnroller eApp — with an internet connection
  • Consumer marketing materials that are ready to distribute
  • A (Excellent) rating from AM Best
  • Agent landing page with everything you need in one convenient place

Get contracted with Medico

2. Great Southern Life (GSL)


GSL out of Kansas City has been one of our favorite carriers. Andrew Kostus and his team in Kansas City continue to earn our business because they do it right!

They have the red and green underwriting system – they were one of the pioneers. Great Southern Life is still picking up speed, and we hope we see them in the 4th quarter as a major player. We love them and hope you do, too!

Highlights of GSL:

  • One of the best processes in the industry - instant underwriting decision with no prescription or doctor information required
  • Easy e-app
  • Great new premium rates
  • Security of an ‘A’ rated company by A.M. Best
  • Increased cash bonus payout of 12.5%! Check out the UFirst Rewards Qualifications

Get contracted with Great Southern Life

1. Mutual of Omaha

mutual of omaha

It would not be right if I didn't bring up Mutual of Omaha. MoO goes back to the 60s with the inception of Medicare.

Mutual of Omaha has great trips, great incentives, and they've been a great partner.

Their paper is as good as anyone's out there. We hope you don't forget about Mutual of Omaha! They do it right.

Mutual of Omaha highlights:

  • "A+" Rated by A.M. Best
  • Med Supp Marketing Credits – 1 credit = $1
  • Very Easy Electronic Applications - Never Leave Your Home of Office!
  • Great Customer Service and Policy Discounts (up to 12% in many states)
  • No App Fee
  • Brand Recognition by Consumers
  • Available in all states except Massachusetts

Get contracted with Mutual of Omaha


We love to go into the Annual Enrollment Period and let everyone know what companies are hot. We hope this helps you ensure you're being as competitive as you can be in your space.

Don't forget to utilize our quote engine to double-check who has the most competitive rates in your county!

Download our Med Supp Tip Sheets

Related Posts