What’s the Best 5-Year Fixed Annuity?

We’ve recently had agents calling in asking about the “best” 5-year fixed annuity.

We have 4 carriers that we recommend the most, so we wanted to explain why. We’ve also included some rate comparisons.

Before we continue, a few quick things:

  1. You can always access up-to-date annuity rates by visiting our Annuity Rates page. This is also included in the weekly email newsletter.
  2. If you’re just starting out with annuities, this article gives some fantastic advice: 5 Agents’ advice for getting started selling annuities
  3. If you’ve started selling annuities, you’ve probably come across these questions (we have answers): Annuity Q&A for Agents: Top Sales Experts Answer Your Trickiest Questions

OK, for the 4 carriers we’re going to talk about, you probably want to know about the comp. As far as comp ratings go, here’s the hierarchy from best to worst:

  1. KSKJ
  2. WULA (Western United Life Assurance, which is the new sister company of Manhattan Life)
  3. ACL and Sentinel (same comp)

For the following rate comparisons, everything is identical except that ACL and Sentinel have a 10% free withdrawal included. If this feature is important to your client, those two carriers might be the best option.

The client in this example is a 67-year-old male, and his deposit is for $400,000.

  WULA Sentinel ACL KSKJ
Annuity Value After Year 5 $465,965.02 $465,287.49 $464,818.79 $463,711
Amount Gained $65,965.02 $65,287.49 $64,818.79 $63,711

As you can see, WULA has the best return, but the 10% free withdrawal is not included. However, after year 1, the client can take out the interest, which is 3% or better – anything up to the RMD level is fair game.

It’s also important to note that WULA has a low-band and high-band interest rate. So, if the deposit is over $250k, the client gets the high-band interest rate, which is 3.10%. If they deposit below $250k (minimum of $10k), they get the low-band interest rate, which is 3.0%.

If it’s crucial for the client to be able to take out a larger sum of money, Sentinel and ACL have the 10% free withdrawal included.

What about that KSKJ Rocket Annuity?

You’ve probably noticed the flyers from KSKJ boasting a 3.25% interest rate. It’s a fantastic deal – and it’s only for a limited time.

A couple things to note about this rocket annuity:

  • It doesn’t allow for penalty-free withdrawals, which means this is only good for those who don’t need access to the money
  • The deposit is $50,000-$150,000 (your client must be willing to deposit within these guidelines)

The bottom line is that you have to be contracted with KSKJ, and you have to have the right client in order for this deal to make sense.

If you have any questions about these annuities, or you want some custom rates, please don’t think twice about getting in touch with me. You can email or call me using the links below, or you can start a chat in the bottom right corner of this screen.

Email Kirk Call Kirk

Do you have a comment? Please share your thoughts below.

Newsletter Signup

Recent Posts

Selling the Lasso Healthcare MSA: Interview With Linda Sprague

Steve Spinner discusses the Lasso Healthcare MSA with agent Linda Sprague. Listen to their discussion about selling the Lasso Healthcare MSA, the...

Read more »

Recognizing Our Heroes This Veterans Day

The celebration or recognition of Veterans Day is something that we all take very seriously. I am the proud father of three great kids, and I have...

Read more »

Can a Veteran On VA Benefits Get the Lasso MSA?

The brand-new Lasso Medical Savings Account (MSA) is gaining a ton of traction, which means we're starting to get more in-depth questions about the...

Read more »

Is the Lasso MSA Better Than a High-Deductible Plan F?

By Steve Spinner and John Hockaday A question we’ve seen a lot from independent agents is this: how does the Lasso Medicare Medical Savings Account...

Read more »
More News »

Do you have a comment about this post? Share your thoughts below.